What did you take the in out of in in for?
You're half-tempted just to repunctuate this one (mmm, a comma after "Charlotte" looks about right), but the problem's worse than that. Somebody forgot to count the parts of speech before driving away, and somewhere in North Carolina, a poor preposition is standing by the highway with a sign that just says "Mother."*
It's the nature of phrasal verbs to draw their meaning from the union of verb and preposition -- not necessarily greater than the sum of the parts, but different. "Turn your paper" and "turn your paper in" are two different suggestions. "Screw up a two-car funeral" isn't a comment about screwing or direction, but about "screwing up."
What we really need is "Man turns himself in in Charlotte slaying": "Turns himself in" for what went on** and "in Charlotte slaying" providing the circumstances. So let's give a big old midtown welcome to the Six Stranded Prepositions: Dear editors, what did you take the in out of in in for?
* Today's trivia question: How cold was it?
** This one seems like it has to be split if the object is a pronoun: "He turned in the suspects" or "he turned them in,"but not "he turned in them."
It's the nature of phrasal verbs to draw their meaning from the union of verb and preposition -- not necessarily greater than the sum of the parts, but different. "Turn your paper" and "turn your paper in" are two different suggestions. "Screw up a two-car funeral" isn't a comment about screwing or direction, but about "screwing up."
What we really need is "Man turns himself in in Charlotte slaying": "Turns himself in" for what went on** and "in Charlotte slaying" providing the circumstances. So let's give a big old midtown welcome to the Six Stranded Prepositions: Dear editors, what did you take the in out of in in for?
* Today's trivia question: How cold was it?
** This one seems like it has to be split if the object is a pronoun: "He turned in the suspects" or "he turned them in,"but not "he turned in them."
3 Comments:
I prefer "What did you take the in in in in out for?" myself :-D
ps - ** This one seems like it has to be split if the object is a preposition: "He turned in the suspects" or "he turned them in,"but not "he turned in them."
I think you mean "pronoun", and that different treatment of pronoun objects is a hallmark of these verbs. A noun object has optional placement after the particle; a pronoun object MUST be placed before it. Compare "put the book up, put up the book, put it up, *put up it", or "look the word up, look up the word, look it up, *look up it", or "turn the tv on, turn on the tv, turn it on, *turn on it" - or my favorite example, "she turned him on" with "she turned on him".
Yes. Pronoun. Grr. Tnx.
I like the 'in in in in' sequence. Surely there's a way to work a seventh preposition in there somewhere?
Post a Comment
<< Home